Glen Canyon: Stealth Herbicide Use

Some time back, we’d posted an article about the puzzling brown spot in Glen Canyon Park, around a rock near a trail. It looked like herbicide use, but regular visitors to the park hadn’t seen the signs SF Rec and Park must post before spraying herbicides. Also, as the picture below shows, it was close to a trail. Both the Natural Areas Program and the Department of the Environment had said there would be no spraying for 15 feet on either side of a trail. We asked them what was going on, and got no answer.

Now we know.

A “volunteer” was spotted spraying the area early one morning.We’d heard anecdotal reports, but this time, an actual incident was reported to us with evidence of unsupervised use of unapproved products without warning notices, and without public records, in a place where pesticides are not supposed to be sprayed.

Rock formation in Glen Canyon Park

These pictures show the pesticide being used in precisely the area we were concerned about.

So in addition to the recorded herbicide use by the Natural Areas Program, there’s unrecorded and unquantified toxins being used in Glen Canyon by sympathizers.

The herbicide in use – at least on this occasion, as far as we could gauge – was Roundup Ready-to-Use Plus.  The product is described on sale websites as not “pet and livestock-friendly.”

It is not on the Department of the Environment’s approved list of pesticides for use on city-owned properties.

WHAT IS ROUNDUP READY-TO-USE PLUS?

This product contains Glyphosate (the main ingredient in all types of Roundup products, which we’ve described in an earlier article). It also contains Pelargonic Acid, which the University of Florida IFAS extension described as “like diquat.”

About pelargonic acid, the Material Safety Data Sheet  (linked here as a PDF) says “Potential for mobility in soil is very high.”  This means it doesn’t stay where it’s sprayed. It moves around.It also says it is slightly toxic to marine organisms – fish and amphibians.

Besides glyphosate and pelargonic acid, Roundup Ready-to-Use Plus contains “other ingredients” that the manufacturer, Monsanto, does not (and is not required to) reveal.

HOW MUCH TOXIN IN GLEN CANYON?

This makes it clear that no one actually knows how much (or what) pesticides are being sprayed in Glen Canyon.

The Natural Areas Program (NAP) sprayed this park at least 6 times in 2011. Clearly, sympathizers are also spraying it with unapproved products not safe for pets and wildlife, without posting warning notices, and without keeping any public records. It’s likely that they are spraying even more frequently than the NAP – which is apparently turning a blind eye to the problem.

The NAP is based on community “stewardship.”  Evidently, this has encouraged its “volunteers” take matters into their own hands and work unsupervised in ways that threaten our environment.

About these ads

12 Responses to Glen Canyon: Stealth Herbicide Use

  1. LC says:

    typical behavior from these folks. they are a cult and determined to do whatever they want, no matter the cost to public health. and they are destroying trees in times of climate change? pretty bad policy.

  2. Alicia Snow says:

    this is so heart breaking! Of course this would be an excellent method of avoiding legal action, if you can blame it all on volunteers as opposed to employees!

    Sent from my iPad

  3. Paul Castleman says:

    next time someone should get a picture (and if possible name) of the sprayer. it’s against the law to destroy park property.

  4. Million Trees says:

    Vandalism in San Francisco’s parks by native park advocates has been going on for nearly 20 years. That story is told here: http://milliontrees.me/2012/07/10/vandalism-by-native-plant-advocates-2/

  5. Pingback: Fact Check: Nothing Grows Under Eucalyptus? (Allelopathy) | Save Mount Sutro Forest

  6. dolan eargle says:

    For heaven’s ( and our) sake. Is there not a police number to call on this obviously illegal use? how long can this go on w/o seriously stopping it? -dolan eargle

    ________________________________

    Webmaster: We’re trying to get action on this. We’re concerned that it might not be an isolated instance.

  7. Pingback: Standing Room Only at SFForest’s Glen Park Meeting « San Francisco Forest Alliance

  8. Pingback: SFForest Public Meeting, 6 Oct 2012: Report « Save the Trees of Glen Canyon Park, San Francisco

  9. Pingback: Natural Areas Program – Under the Radar with the 2008 Bond in Glen Canyon « San Francisco Forest Alliance

  10. Pingback: SF’s Natural Areas Program Uses Even More Pesticides « San Francisco Forest Alliance

  11. Pingback: SF’s Natural Areas Program Uses Even More Pesticides | Save Mount Sutro Forest

  12. Pingback: Golden Spring in Glen Canyon « Save the Trees of Glen Canyon Park, San Francisco

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 455 other followers